Seite - 1589 - in Book of Full Papers - Symposium Hydro Engineering
Bild der Seite - 1589 -
Text der Seite - 1589 -
1. LITERATURE REVIEW
1.1. SOURCE OF ERRORS; HOW CHALLENGING THE MATTER IS?
A total pressure cell installed in the body of an earth-fill, e.g. in the clay core
of an embankment dam, must be capable to measure the total stress in a special
direction. In many instances, the position of pressure cell changes continuously
due to the development of displacements and functionally changes the value of
measured pressure. This is the most important reason for the inconsistent total
pressure data and uncertainty of monitoring results of embankment structures.
This uncertainty can cause some misunderstanding of pressure data and related
pressure ratios – such as Arching Ratio - and following mistakes of monitoring.
The rotation of the total pressure cells in the soil material during compaction
of an embankment is very likely. Therefore, the analysis of pressure data in an
embankment without knowledge of final inclination of the pressure cell is a
challenging matter, which sometimes causes resign form installation of total
pressure cell.
For reviewing the literature of researches and studies, it would be very helpful
starting with the GIN (Geotechnical Instrumentation News) which included an
article by Ali Mirghasemi about total pressure cells of Karkheh dam in the 46th
episode and subsequently discussions in the next episode. The exchange of ideas
mentioned as below about no consistent total pressure data is being still discussed
among the manufacturers, geotechnical institutes and consulting companies. The
conclusion of Mr. Dunnicliff for this very interesting theme is generally accepted for
principle of stress monitoring in embankment dams.
ʺ A total of 102 clusters, each of five earth pressure cells, have been installed
to determine the total stresses in the embankment – a total of 510 cells. This
number is about half of total number of instruments installed in the dam. No
consistent data was achieved from the earth pressure cells. ʺ Ali Asghar
Mirghasemi, Assistant Professor, University of Tehran; GIN March 2006 [Ref. 1]
ʺ In summary, measurement of total stress in an embankment is extremely
difficult and should not be done unless absolutely necessary and, if necessary,
particular care must be given to installation details. ʺ Elmo DiBiagio, Norwegian
Geotechnical Institute (NGI); GIN June 2006 [Ref. 2]
ʺ My experiences with free field total pressure cells have also been
disappointing and the cost of their installation in the clay core of a dam is not
justified, in my opinion. The results are rarely reliable. ʺ P. Erik Mikkelsen,
Geoengineering & Instrumentation, Geometron Inc.; GIN June 2006 [Ref. 2]
ʺ My experience is, and that of many authors at ICOLD Congresses and other
Conferences seems to be, that it is very difficult to interpret and rely on the readings
from earth pressure cells installed in embankment dams, especially rockfill dams.
Many investigators have spent time and money installing such cells, but have, in
general, found the measurements of little value. There are examples of pressure
cells giving valuable readings when the cells are installed on a structural interface,
but not inside the dam body. ʺ John Dunnicliff; GIN June 2006 [Ref. 2]
1589
Book of Full Papers
Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Titel
- Book of Full Papers
- Untertitel
- Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Autor
- Gerald Zenz
- Verlag
- Verlag der Technischen Universität Graz
- Ort
- Graz
- Datum
- 2018
- Sprache
- englisch
- Lizenz
- CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
- ISBN
- 978-3-85125-620-8
- Abmessungen
- 20.9 x 29.6 cm
- Seiten
- 2724
- Schlagwörter
- Hydro, Engineering, Climate Changes
- Kategorien
- International
- Naturwissenschaften Physik
- Technik