Seite - 1989 - in Book of Full Papers - Symposium Hydro Engineering
Bild der Seite - 1989 -
Text der Seite - 1989 -
The overall differences are as follows.
(1) The description of Chinese technology standards focuses on the
requirements of principle and lack specific guidance on how to operate, leading to
the difficulties for designers to understand and apply them. But at the same time,
Chinese standards involve more contents and clauses than American standards.
On the contrary, the American standards pay more attention to the instruction and
explanation of operation methods, which is relatively comfortable to understand.
Sometimes, it may adopt a long length to illustrate a concept or method, which
Results in less content coverage.
(2) Chinese standards sum up a lot of experience, design parameters and
requirements, the design and construction work of architecture can be completed
according to the requirements of the code. However, it is easy to ignore the
application and analysis of the basic theory. American standards attach great
importance to the application of basic theory and for the specific project design,
American standards can help engineers carry out a large number of calculation
and analysis, giving full play to the initiative of engineers.
(3) The United States standards count the accidents statistics happened in
constructed structures from the government level and develop deep analysis into
published research findings which have great reference value to similar
engineering projects. Chinese standards, by contrast, rarely involve engineering
situation which causes many precious experience locked in a very small scope and
hinders the exchange and process of technology. So It is suggested that the work
of accident analysis and experience exchange should be upgraded to the
government level.
(4) The source of many regulations can be found in American standards by
the lists of related research references. Chinese standards, however, just give a
pure rule which should be strictly implemented causing engineers not to know why
they should do like this. For example, about the calculation of the thickness or
length of the upstream pavement of the earth rockfill dam constructed on sand and
gravel foundation, American standards give the reference of theoretical design
method of pavement: “Bennett P.T. The Effect of Blankets on Seepage Through
Pervious Foundations. Trans. ASCE, vol. Ⅲ, 1946.”. Chinese standards just give
an explanation that the pavement should be gradually thickened from the upstream
to the downstream, and the minimum thickness of the front end should be 0.5-
1.0m. And any reference can’t be found.
(5) On the whole, Chinese standards, in which the requirements on design
and construction are incline to keep safe, are stricter than American standards.
Chinese standards care about ensuring structures’ safety and stability, but
simultaneously the cost also increases, which may cause the waste of materials.
For example, Chinese standards require the depth of curtain grouting up to the
aquifers, but American standards don’t have this requirement.
3.2. DIFFERENCES ON MAIN COMPARE POINTS
3.2.1. Position of the base level for foundation
Chinese standards determine the base level for foundation by the weathering
degree of rock mass(SL) or the the grading of rock mass (DL) The SL’s standards
stipulate that “when the dam height exceeds 100m, it can be built on fresh, slightly
1989
Book of Full Papers
Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Titel
- Book of Full Papers
- Untertitel
- Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Autor
- Gerald Zenz
- Verlag
- Verlag der Technischen Universität Graz
- Ort
- Graz
- Datum
- 2018
- Sprache
- englisch
- Lizenz
- CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
- ISBN
- 978-3-85125-620-8
- Abmessungen
- 20.9 x 29.6 cm
- Seiten
- 2724
- Schlagwörter
- Hydro, Engineering, Climate Changes
- Kategorien
- International
- Naturwissenschaften Physik
- Technik