Seite - 2121 - in Book of Full Papers - Symposium Hydro Engineering
Bild der Seite - 2121 -
Text der Seite - 2121 -
In the exterior zones of the rock mass, the permeability reaches and exceeds
10-6 m/s. Along the headrace tunnel in sound rock the permeability stays below 10-7
m/s. The tunnel was almost dry with only shear zones notably discharging water.
REVIEW OF DESIGN CONCEPTS
The rock outcrops on the walls of the Quitaracsa canyon are virtually
inaccessible, but some information could be derived from the experience with the
construction of the Cañon del Pato hydropower plant in the immediate vicinity. On
this basis, favorable conditions for the underground works were predicted, with Q
> 40 for most of the length of the pressure tunnel. Accordingly, an unlined tunnel,
only locally supported with shotcrete and bolts, and a 75 m long penstock in the
stretch immediately upstream of the power cavern was foreseen. However, a
review identified uncertainties in the assumptions with potential impacts for the
design and performance of the headrace tunnel. These were primarily:
Level and pattern of stresses along the tunnel route were unknown. This
condition significantly affects the Q-rating and is decisively important in
relation to potential hydrojacking of the rock mass due to the high pressure in
the tunnel.
There was no information on hydrogeological characteristics and regime in the
rock mass. Discontinuities, specifically shears, traversing the tunnel (Figure 2
right) could convey tunnel seepage towards the canyon and, with the pre-
vailing rock mass structure, locally destabilize the slopes. In several locations,
the tunnel alignment did not meet the “Australian Criterion” (Dann et al. [1]) for
horizontal lateral cover.
These reservations were debated, alleging that, (a) the route of the headrace
tunnel complies with the Norwegian criterion, and (b) the saturation line, calculated
according to Bouvard [2] stays safely inside the slope.
However, these arguments are flawed: the respective analyses ignored
conditions implicit to the application of the methods. The original Norwegian
criterion, as e. g. formulated by Broch [3] assumes σh/σv≈1, a condition, which quite
frequently obtains, but is by no means guaranteed. The saturation line, as the title
implies, applies to “terrain sec”, with free vertical drainage, which is not the case
for the Quitaracsa headrace tunnel.
Figure 5 shows σ3 contours, the groundwater table and flow lines, simulated
by FE-model, with the “saturation line” superimposed. The saturation line rises
above the groundwater table, i. e. this method indicates a higher external head
than the FE simulation and, in consequence, reduced risk of hydrojacking. In the
FE model, the seepage flow from the tunnel drains towards the river, whereas the
saturation line would have the seepage disappearing in the depth of the rock mass,
which in this case is impossible.
The results of geotechnical and hydrogeological model simulation depend on
the input, its completeness and reliability and, therefore, have to be viewed with
due reservations. Nevertheless, in this case they clearly demonstrate the
2121
Book of Full Papers
Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Titel
- Book of Full Papers
- Untertitel
- Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Autor
- Gerald Zenz
- Verlag
- Verlag der Technischen Universität Graz
- Ort
- Graz
- Datum
- 2018
- Sprache
- englisch
- Lizenz
- CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
- ISBN
- 978-3-85125-620-8
- Abmessungen
- 20.9 x 29.6 cm
- Seiten
- 2724
- Schlagwörter
- Hydro, Engineering, Climate Changes
- Kategorien
- International
- Naturwissenschaften Physik
- Technik