Page - 136 - in Austrian Law Journal, Volume 2/2019
Image of the Page - 136 -
Text of the Page - 136 -
ALJ 2019 Hartlieb 136
with the notarial deed obligation (section 1(1d) NotAktG) or notarial certification (section 518 BGB).
If the parties do not comply with the notarial deed obligation or the notarial certification, the
transaction is deemed to be a non-formal obligation.75 As such, it does not entail any legal
obligations and therefore does not have to be reported. In this respect, the regulation is the same
as in the case of transactions subject to a preceding condition.76
In Germany, the time of acceptance of an inheritance (section 1943 BGB) is decisive for the
acquisition of financial instruments by way of inheritance. If the inheritance is subsequently
disputed, this can also trigger the obligation to notify.77 In Austria, it is not necessary to report the
submission of the declaration of inheritance because it is not certain at this point that the manager
will receive the financial instruments available in the estate. Rather, the decisive point in time is
the allocation of the financial instruments by a legally binding order of inheritance. If the manager
receives financial instruments subject to the reporting obligation as a legacy, the acquisition under
property law must be considered for factual reasons.78
D. De Minimis Threshold
Transactions on the managers’ account whose total volume does not exceed the threshold of €
5,000 per calendar year need not be reported, pursuant to Art 19(1)(ii) in conjunction with (8) MAR.
This threshold previously took into account the fact that low-volume transactions have little or no
signal effect on the investor public.79 Now it serves above all to protect the investor public from an
information overload caused by (too) many reports and the responsible authorities from work
overload.80 The threshold value of € 5,000 is calculated by adding all transactions without netting.
The effects of opposing transactions, such as the purchase and sale of financial instruments, must
therefore not be netted, but added together.81
According to Art 19(8) MAR, the obligation to report shall apply "to any subsequent transaction
once a total amount of EUR 5,000 has been reached". According to para 1 subpara 2 leg cit, the
report shall be made “once the total amount of transactions has reached the threshold set out in
paragraph 8 (...) within a calendar year”. Contrary to the ambiguous wording, already the
transaction with which the threshold is exceeded must be reported.82 Otherwise, an individual
75 See Heribert Löcker, § 943, in Online-Kommentar zum ABGB, 8 (Andreas Kletečka/Martin Schauer eds, 2016);
regarding the notarial deed form, see Marie-Therese Fritzer, Form der Schenkung 5 et seq, 265 et seq (2018).
76 The parallel to transactions subject to a preceding condition can also be seen in § 1 (1) d NotAktG: „Die Giltigkeit
der nachbezeichneten Verträge und Rechtshandlungen ist durch die Aufnahme eines Notariatsactes über
dieselben bedingt“; see also Fritzer, supra note 75, at 42, 88 et seq.
77 BaFin, supra note 68, Frage IV.7.
78 In the event of the testator’s death, the legatee receives a claim under the law of obligations against the estate
(section 684 of the Austrian Civil Code (Allgemeines BĂĽrgerliches Gesetzbuch; ABGB)). However, the manager will
often only become aware of this at a later point in time - namely in the course of the probate proceedings. If the
focus were on the time the manager receives the claim, he or she would often not be able to fulfil his or her duty
to report within the prescribed period.
79 See Hartlieb & Simonishvili, supra note 14, at 63.
80 Recital 58 MAR; Kumpan, supra note 13, at 454.
81 Kumpan, supra note 13, at 454.
82 Stephan Semrau, Art 19, in Kommentar zur Marktmissbrauchsverordnung, 54 (Lars Klöhn ed, 2018); BaFin, supra
note 68, Frage III.2.
back to the
book Austrian Law Journal, Volume 2/2019"
Austrian Law Journal
Volume 2/2019
- Title
- Austrian Law Journal
- Volume
- 2/2019
- Author
- Karl-Franzens-Universität Graz
- Editor
- Brigitta Lurger
- Elisabeth Staudegger
- Stefan Storr
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2019
- Language
- English
- License
- CC BY 4.0
- Size
- 19.1 x 27.5 cm
- Pages
- 17
- Keywords
- Recht, Gesetz, Rechtswissenschaft, Jurisprudenz
- Categories
- Zeitschriften Austrian Law Journal