Page - 115 - in Biodiversity and Health in the Face of Climate Change
Image of the Page - 115 -
Text of the Page - 115 -
115
regularly and are satisfied with its quality, the same (or similar) outdoor space is not
supporting the needs of young to middle-aged adults. The authors showed that
judgements about the quality aspects of urban green space vary across age groups,
but place more importance on utilising green space than either on the size of green
space or on proximity. Understanding how all these attributes interact and translate
into health outcomes is one direction for future research.
Interestingly, results of only two studies were based on objective health mea-
surements (Michael etÂ
al. 2014 through clinical examination for detecting obesity;
Richardson et al. 2017a using accelerometry for detecting physical activity). All
other studies under reviewÂ
used secondary data from official statistics or data from
health questionnaires where respondents reported their health status themselves,
mostly through well-developed Likert scale measurements for perceived health. In
the two studies using objective measures, no consistent association between health
and urban green space was identified. One could argue that objectively measured
health is the most reliable because it might be less biased by indirect indicators or
perceptions. There are, however, other studies that use objective measures to assess
potential links between stress levels and urban green space, e.g. through cortisol
levels or electroencephalography (Ward Thompson et al. 2012; Aspinall et al.
2013). In these studies, stress levels were found to decrease in greener environ-
ments. Stress levels, however, always depend on many different aspects that may
lead to an increase or decrease in stress levels. A combination of both subjective
and objective measurements is an important field for future research.
Focus on the method of measurement is worth discussing here. All studies used
and produced quantitative data and conducted statistical analyses. The review
showed that important results were produced from this approach. No study in this
review used qualitative research methods, such as an ethnographic approach that
includes assessments of observing free behaviour. For children of a particular age
group, Chawla (2015) pointed out that ethnographic approaches show how green
space can contribute to the development of children’s capabilities and to their
“complete physical, mental and social well-being”. Echoing Chawla (2015), future
research should combine qualitative and quantitative approaches that include eth-
nographic assessment (see Kabisch and Haase 2014; Low 2013 for further details),
but also experimental and correlational methods that, when used together, may
increase the understanding of health and the environment.
The selection of particular search terms for the review has, of course, produced
somewhat narrow results. Using other search terms may have contributed to a
larger evidence base on the urban green space-health outcome association, e.g.
through increasing the scope to other types of nature, such as trees. However, the
focus of this review was to look at potential confounding factors that may explain
health- outcome results, and to urban green spaces as a broad group of urban nature.
Further, by limiting the review to recent studies, older studies are omitted, although
they certainly are as important to review and discuss, especially as they relate to
confounding variables.
5 The Influence of Socio-economic and Socio-demographic Factors inÂ
the Association…
Biodiversity and Health in the Face of Climate Change
- Title
- Biodiversity and Health in the Face of Climate Change
- Authors
- Melissa Marselle
- Jutta Stadler
- Horst Korn
- Katherine Irvine
- Aletta Bonn
- Publisher
- Springer Open
- Date
- 2019
- Language
- English
- License
- CC BY 4.0
- ISBN
- 978-3-030-02318-8
- Size
- 15.5 x 24.0 cm
- Pages
- 508
- Keywords
- Environment, Environmental health, Applied ecology, Climate change, Biodiversity, Public health, Regional planning, Urban planning
- Categories
- Naturwissenschaften Umwelt und Klima