Page - 150 - in JRFM - Journal Religion Film Media, Volume 05/02
Image of the Page - 150 -
Text of the Page - 150 -
Given that most Mormons – including the leadership of the LDS Church – un-
derstand the Lamanite prophecies to apply particularly to people of Latin Amer-
ican descent, it becomes literally impossible for the Second Coming to occur
without immigration to the United States. Certainly, not all US Mormons – or
even most – favor undocumented immigration or immigrants;38 neverthe-
less, the LDS leadership (and many members) favor a liberalized approach to
US-Mexican border policies that will keep families together and allow people to
work in the country if they are not committing major crimes.39 Napoleon Dyna-
mite clearly communicates a pro-immigrant discourse even as it signals Mexican
people as Other. The film never overtly clamors for immigrant rights, but it is
important to note that there is no reference to La Migra (immigration enforce-
ment), nor does anyone question Pedro’s right to be in the town. Napoleon
Dynamite’s ambiguous representation of immigrants and immigration makes it
difficult to place in relation to other examples of popular culture. Some of Hess’s
illegibility to a broader US audience almost certainly results from a complex ra-
cial determinism that he has inherited from his faith in which Mexicans are on
the one hand foreign Others and on the other hand a chosen people destined
to (re)populate North America. Hess’s eccentric representation of Mexican and
Mexican-American culture makes it difficult to categorize his work as a social
justice film, but his use of a charismatic immigrant for a major protagonist places
him at odds with films focused on national security and/or securing the border.
The movie reverberates with a rarely taught, though canonical, aspect of
Mormon doctrine that holds that the Lamanites will “return” to the land of the
Gentiles (read: the United States) after the Gentiles have drifted away from the
faith. One of the most interesting events of the Book of Mormon details the ar-
rival of Christ to the Americas following his crucifixion and resurrection. At one
point, Jesus himself prophecises,
It shall come to pass that whosoever will not believe in my words, who am Jesus
Christ, which the Father shall cause him to bring forth unto the Gentiles, and shall
give unto him power that he shall bring them forth unto the Gentiles, (it shall be
done even as Moses said) they shall be cut off from among my people who are of
38 Indeed, Arizona’s infamous HB 1070 was championed by the Mormon state senator Russell
Pearce. What is more, The Salt Lake Tribune reported that “a little less than half of Mormons in
the state agree with the Utah Compact, despite the church leaders’ support of the document
that seeks to keep local police from enforcing federal immigration laws”. See Montero 2011.
39 The Church’s most recent public declaration about immigration focused primarily on keeping
families together; however, it also recognized the right of sovereign states to “enforce [their]
laws and secure [their] borders”. See Immigration 2011. The Church’s relaxed policy toward
illegal immigration is especially visible with regard to policies surrounding membership. The
Church will not allow investigators to be baptized if they are currently breaking the law or
serving a prison or probation sentence. That said, undocumented immigrants can be baptized
despite being in the country illegally. See van Uitert 2007, 309.
150 | David S. Dalton www.jrfm.eu 2019, 5/2, 141–165
JRFM
Journal Religion Film Media, Volume 05/02
- Title
- JRFM
- Subtitle
- Journal Religion Film Media
- Volume
- 05/02
- Authors
- Christian Wessely
- Daria Pezzoli-Olgiati
- Editor
- Uni-Graz
- Publisher
- SchĂĽren Verlag GmbH
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2019
- Language
- English
- License
- CC BY-NC 4.0
- Size
- 14.8 x 21.0 cm
- Pages
- 219
- Categories
- Zeitschriften JRFM