Page - 122 - in Limina - Grazer theologische Perspektiven, Volume 2:1
Image of the Page - 122 -
Text of the Page - 122 -
122 | www.limina-graz.eu
hande Birkalan-Gedik | muslim | martyr | masculine
or rather the “military idea” originated as and continues to be a gendered
discourse perpetuated by Turkish nationalism as well as the practices of
military service and education. This idealized, hegemonic masculinity sig-
nificantly determines the “male” experience of Mehmetçik—the unknown
soldier, the little Mehmet. As Jenny White also underlined, it is difficult for
women to define their place as national subjects. Women can do so only
“as mothers of martyrs or as citizens perhaps, but not as national subjects.
Indeed, nationalist—whether secular or Muslim—is a masculine term with
which few women are able or willing to affiliate” (White 2013, 19).
Furthermore, the militarist idea of masculinity is also heterosexual and
heteronormative: While military service is not mandatory for women, they
can choose to serve in the military by joining the military in a profession-
al capacity. It is also interesting to note that Kemalism recognized Sabiha
Gökçen, one of the adoptive daughters of Mustafa Kemal, as the first female
war pilot in military history as a way to promote strong, masculine roles for
women. Although the first female to fly a plane is Belkıs Şevket, a feminist
who boarded and flew a plane in 1913, this has been erased from the pub-
lic memory and images of Sabiha Gökçen have been planted in the minds
of many Turkish people instead. While transgressing masculine categories
was allowed and even encouraged for women, being “openly” gay cannot
be tolerated in the masculinist, militarist understanding. Masculinity, with
reference to a national identity, is therefore hegemonic: Masculinities do
not have to correspond closely to the lives of actual men. “Yet these models
do, in various ways, express widespread ideals, fantasies, and desires,” as
Connel and Messerschmidt argued in their discussion of “hegemonic mas-
culinity” (2005, 838). The ideal Turkish male, a male “person,” is defined
as someone who has completed the compulsory military service, otherwise
he is not a “man” yet. As such, he cannot be gainfully employed, because
probably no company will employ him without performing a military ser-
vice which would then imply that he does not want to do his military ser-
vice. He is not yet allowed to be married because he is not mature, as many
believe in the “moralizing” function of the military in that it builds char-
acter and sharpens the ego (see Sinclair-Webb 2006 for more details on the
meaning and function of the military for boys and young men). As such,
the military can become both a producer of and a repository for masculin-
The ideal Turkish male has completed the military
service, otherwise he is not a “man” yet.
Limina
Grazer theologische Perspektiven, Volume 2:1
- Title
- Limina
- Subtitle
- Grazer theologische Perspektiven
- Volume
- 2:1
- Editor
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Date
- 2019
- Language
- German
- License
- CC BY-NC 4.0
- Size
- 21.4 x 30.1 cm
- Pages
- 194
- Categories
- Zeitschriften LIMINA - Grazer theologische Perspektiven