Page - 25 - in Mobile Culture Studies - The Journal, Volume 1/2015
Image of the Page - 25 -
Text of the Page - 25 -
25Mobile
culture Studies. The Journal 1 2o15
Joachim Schlör | The sea voyage as a transitory experience
(with Gerald Lamprecht) a workshop on this topic and to invite a number of colleagues to pre-
sent their research. Thus the focus widened considerably, including papers on migration from
Poland (Elisabeth Janik) and to Argentina (Philipp Mettauer). The call for Papers for this issue
produced – fortunately, I think – an even wider perspective on the topic: with contributions
on sea voyage experiences by noted anthropologists (Arnd Schneider), on 19th century sources
that document the transatlantic crossings of German female travellers (Ursula feldkamp) and
of Swiss emigrants from Appenzell (Sabine August), but also on mediated representations in
graphic novels and films (Anja fuchs, Robin Klengel), on the lifestyle of „liveaboards“ on the
Mediterranean Sea (Nataša Rogelja), and on the current situation of refugees between Turkey
and Greece (Estela Schindel).
„The current situation“ is, obviously, a euphemism. The Mediterranean Sea today is the
theatre of a profound tragedy. Refugees from the African continent try desperately to reach the
coasts of Europe, in Lampedusa or in Malta, hoping for the security and the freedom that is –
or has been? – the promise of Europe. caught in the in-between-ness of political unrest in their
home countries, the criminal activities of smugglers, and the tightened security measures of the
„fortress Europe“, migrants face death, detention, and deportation. There is no time for them
to reflect on their experiences or to make notes. One might even think that political activism
in support of the refugees would be more urgently required of us today than academic research.
On the other hand, ethnographical and anthropoloical research on migrants‘ experiences does
already take place, in the context of Border Studies or Diaspora Studies, and it may well be that
the „situation“ (including the images we are confronted with daily) challenges, indeed forces
us to re-think and re-conceptualize our ideas about ships, about voyages, and about mobi-
lity in general. In her comments on the papers delivered during the Graz workshop in June
2014, Johanna Rolshoven offered a wide range of theoretical and methodological approaches for
an understanding of both the historical and the contemporary „situations“: of people finding
themselves aboard ships from an old home to a new one.3
What Todd Presner has required of „mobility studies”, not only in the context of Jewish
Studies – „an attention to moving bodies, an emplotment of the places traversed, and a visua-
lization of narratives of dislocation, encounter, and dispersal” 4 –, can be made useful in our
example when theoretical deliberations on the production (Lefebvre) and construction of space
are discussed with regard to, and in respect of, the individual experiences of migrants; when
observations of the material culture (the ship) are brought into a dialogue with personal reflec-
tions about the meaning of the passage for those who travelled across the oceans; in short, when
the passage itself (van Gennep) and the systems related to it (Urry) acquire a human face.
Notions such as „liminality“ (Turner), „threshold“, or „moratorium“, are all tentative
approaches to an understanding of the spatial and temporal in-between-ness which sea voyages
symbolically represent. Leaving and arriving, looking back and looking forward, making travel
arrangements relating to countries – and states of mind – „here“ and „there“, expressing feelings
3 Rolshoven, Johanna. [2014]. Die Schiffsreise als Übergang. Gedanken zur Heuristik des gesellschaftlichen Zwi-
schenraumes. commentary for the attention of the workshop audience „Schiffsreise“, Graz, June 2014, Zentrum
für Jüdische Studien, Institut für Volkskunde und Kulturanthropologie, KfU Graz. E-mail sent to the partici-
pants on 2014-06-26.
4 Ibid. Presner, Todd. 2009. ‘Remapping German-Jewish Studies: Benjamin, cartography, Modernity’, German
Quarterly 82, no. 3 (summer 2009), p. 298.
Mobile Culture Studies
The Journal, Volume 1/2015
- Title
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Subtitle
- The Journal
- Volume
- 1/2015
- Editor
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2015
- Language
- German, English
- License
- CC BY 4.0
- Size
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Pages
- 216
- Categories
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal