Page - 207 - in Mobile Culture Studies - The Journal, Volume 1/2015
Image of the Page - 207 -
Text of the Page - 207 -
Mobile Culture Studies. The Journal 1 2o15
Estela Schindel | Sea border crossing to Europe 207
and asylum regimes limit their possibility of crossing as citizens through regular border crossing
points, these travellers are left with the option of embarking into the open and, in the best case,
being found and saved as mere human beings. Differently from the full citizenship of rights, as
granted by the national state, they are travelling as temporary state-less persons. While trying
to cross outside the regular border control points, refugees and migrants do not count on the
guarantees and privileges of a citizen but, as Giorgio Agamben poses it, they are reduced to
bare life. It is not as citizens of rights, but in their âmereâ biological, undifferentiated existence
that they are object of humanitarian protection. The universal human rights they are supposed
to be granted (although even those are often violated) does not equal citizenship. Instead, by
being pushed into a realm of mere survival, their life is reduced to biological existence without
civil inscription. In Agambenâs (1998) understanding of bare life, they were taken beyond the
threshold of animalization, left alone with their biological subsistence, deprived of the rights
inherent to the qualified life of the citizen.
Several authors have exposed how in diverse EU countries the unwanted asylum seekers
and immigrants are being constructed either as enemies or as a sort of threaten; an operation
that relies on the amalgamation of criminality and migration and is amplified through its
spectacular treatment in the media (See i.g. Dal Lago 1999, Palidda 2011 and the contributions
of ceyhan and Tsoukala in Bigo & Guild, 2005). Read through foucaultâs (2003) definition
of state racism, they are being constructed not as object of an ethnic racism but of a biological
racism; a potential danger the social body. Pushing unwanted border crossers into this biologi-
cized sphere is consistent with those discursive constructions. More recently, the treatment of
detained migrants and refugees has been furthermore interpreted as a sovereign operation of
âanimalizationâ of âirregularâ migrants in the frame of what is constituted as a âzoopolitical
borderâ: a specific spatial technology of power aimed at rendering otherwise âiregularâ populati-
ons knowable and governable and, especially, at immobilizing them (Vaughan-Williams 2015).
Mark Salter (2013) calls the current mobility assemblage, paraphrasing foucault, a power
oriented instead to âmaking move and letting stop.â This principle can be easily applied to the
creation of an uncertain mobility regime, consisting of deterring immigrants and forcing them
to navigate adrift for longer periods, or to look for alternate routes, increasing the duration and
danger of their journeys. foucault (1979) explained how, under the disciplinary societies, power
used to fix the individual to spaces of enclosure. In the contemporary societies of control, accor-
ding to Deleuze (1992), power tends instead to âforms of free-floating control.â The enclosures
and panopticons analyzed by foucault are thus giving place to an undulatory, modulating con-
trol that operates as a continuous network. The new mobility regimes brought along include a
series of practices of movement adrift, indefinite detention, and enormous amounts of waiting,
where illegalized migrants no longer own their own time (Salter 2009). Boats subjected to the
controversial âpush backâ operations must spend much more time on the high seas than a direct
crossing would require; they are forced to keep navigating, unable to reach the coast.
When Paul Virilio, who coined the term âdromologieâ âor the study and science of velo-
cityâ wrote that âspeed is powerâ (1980) he was pointing out the emergence of a new political
configuration: one where power lies not only and not necessarily in the right and possibility to
move â or not to move â but in the capacity to decide and regulate the velocity, rhythm and
flow of (im)mobility, meaning governing (im)mobilities. At the European Borders the (im)
Mobile Culture Studies
The Journal, Volume 1/2015
- Title
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Subtitle
- The Journal
- Volume
- 1/2015
- Editor
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2015
- Language
- German, English
- License
- CC BY 4.0
- Size
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Pages
- 216
- Categories
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal