Page - 73 - in Mobile Culture Studies - The Journal, Volume 2/2016
Image of the Page - 73 -
Text of the Page - 73 -
Mobile Culture Studies. The Journal 2 2o16
Tony Kushner | Lampedusa and the Migrant Crisis 73
passenger, they had left Eritrea, fleeing the military dictatorship and forced conscription. Fanus
had paid smugglers to get her over the border and on through the Sahara to Libyaâ. The Medi-
terranean crossing was thus just âthe final leg of a dangerous, expensive journey in search of
asylum in Europeâ. Her narrative focuses on this and her other failed attempts to escape Eritrea
and how âMy parents sold everything they had to raise the moneyâ â in all it cost over ÂŁ2000.58
In Stockholm some six months after her traumatic arrival in Lampedusa, Fanus (her real
name was withheld to protect her family), reflected with horror on how she got there from
Africa: âI donât want to look back and remember my journey, nobody should have to go through
what we did. I wouldnât wish it on my worst enemy.â 59 But even this truncated account of her
life story, with the focus on the Lampedusa disaster and her life as an âillegalâ immigrant after it,
is exceptional. Fanus burnt her fingertips so as to avoid police recognition. The wider aim was
to avoid return to Italy as place of first arrival under the Dublin Treaty in processing asylum
seekers. Others avoided telling the authorities of their journey to Lampedusa for the same rea-
son. Meron Estefanos, an Eritrean activist who has supported those who survived the October
2013 disaster, relates that âThey are afraid if they tell their story, there is a risk they will be sent
back to Italy so for that reason people choose not to mention they survived the boat tragedy.
They pretend they came a different routeâ. In speaking out, having reached Sweden âillegallyâ,
Fanus âdecided to take her chances. âIf they want to send us back to Italy, weâll tell them Italy
did not treat us right, We just have to be honest.â 60 But it is not only this aspect of their life
stories that such migrants have performed differently from reality â their places of origin and
reasons for leaving have also often been constructed to reflect the reality of European asylum
procedures.
From the moment immigration controls were systematically introduced in the late nine-
teenth century, migrants have shaped both their testimony and their paperwork to improve
their chances of gaining entry. The latest manifestation of this âgameâ (one that can mean life
or death) is migrants performing what they hope will be right narrative for those whose job it is
to keep borders as restrictive as possible. As Caroline Moorehead noted in 2005, when covering
the life of asylum seekers in the north east of England:
Refugee life is rife with rumour. Among those who wait to be interviewed for refugee sta-
tus, word circulates about how some nationalities are more likely to get asylum than others,
about how some stories are more powerful than others, and some more likely to touch the
hearts of the interviewers.
She adds that the âbuying and selling of âgoodâ stories, stories to win asylum, has become com-
mon practice in refugee circles, among people terrified that their own real story is not powerfulâ.
She concludes âHow easy, then, how natural, to shape the past in such a way that it provides
more hope for a better futureâ.61 In the ten years since she published Human Cargo, the level
of control and culture of disbelief has grown and, alongside it, the self-construction of migrant
narratives to resist such tendencies.
58 Nelson, âA long way homeâ.
59 Ibid.
60 Ibid.
61 Moorehead, Human Cargo, 136.
Mobile Culture Studies
The Journal, Volume 2/2016
- Title
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Subtitle
- The Journal
- Volume
- 2/2016
- Editor
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2016
- Language
- German, English
- License
- CC BY 4.0
- Size
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Pages
- 168
- Categories
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal