Page - 168 - in Mobile Culture Studies - The Journal, Volume 3/2017
Image of the Page - 168 -
Text of the Page - 168 -
168 Mobile Culture Studies. The Journal 3
2017Emanuelle
Lenel | Open neighbourhood, closed neighbourhood
in the relationships to the neighbourhood, usually neglected in the «classical» studies of the
regenerated neighbourhoods in terms of gentrification. Indeed, the commented itineraries gave
access to dimensions of the mobility experience when it comes to the body. While the discur-
sive data collected during interviews allowed to report the embodied experience «to the social
and historical conditions of perception» (Chadoin, 2010), i.e. to situate this experience and the
perceived neighbourhood within a social system in order to underline the collective dimension
of the emerging atmospheres. So the paper argues that the atmosphere of openness or closeness
emerging in these neighbourhoods is linked to an unequal capital of mobility.
In the Heyvaert neighbourhoud, the emerging atmosphere for the old owners belonging
to the Moroccan immigration is characterised by oppression. They live in the old houses close
to the car trade activities established in the neighbourhood since the 1990s, and they strongly
experience its pollutions (Lenel, 2015) as an invasion in their privacy. Furthermore they do not
have the economic means (no prospect of residential mobility) to escape from this «lost neigh-
bourhood». They so suffer these pollutions as well as the proximity with other immigrants more
precarious than them. Conversely, the emerging atmosphere for the new owners is characterised
by the feeling to live in a neighbourhood connected to the oustide: this metropolitan population
live in a new building facing the canal at one end of the neighbourhood, where these pollutions
are less perceived and where they can more easily access their activities, scattered in the city.
The Vieux Molenbeek is a neighbourhood in transition, combining strong traces of its flo-
riscent industrial past, material degradation and its future as a part of the expanded city center.
According to what is seized of these promises of future, reminiscences of the past or hesitati-
ons of the present, the emerging atmospheres for old or new owners are not contemporary to
each other. For the old owners also belonging to the Moroccan immigration, installed in the
neighbourhood sometimes for several decades, the emerging atmosphere is the one of a «beau-
tiful village» getting lost, reminiscent of their social success as immigrated workers. But this
village is limited to the old degraded spaces marked by a narrow atmosphere, where traveling is
uncomfortable. While the atmosphere commented by the new owners, living in the renovated
spaces of the neighbourhood, is the one of a «small theater of life» (Bidou, 1984), a convivial and
cosmopolitan urban landscape to which they do not really participate. This strong atmosphere
but that does not capture them allows them to cross the neighbourhood to get the city center
without feeling caught in its density and presencies (noise, dirt, individuals).
Finally, these analyses support an hypothesis: the «felt mobility» is an unequally distributed
resource for the management of proximity to the other in the targeted neighbourhoods that
are urbanistically and demographically dense. The «felt mobility» for old and new owners has
indeed very contrasted effects on the modes of attention and the affects to the other, the distur-
bing one in particular that is more or less easily held at a «good distance». The feelings of being
able to be elsewhere that there give the new owners the necessary game so as not to be absorbed
in a time-space of constrained copresence, and allows to update «intellectualist» dispositions
to tolerance (Simmel, 2004[1993]). While the old owners more involved in the thickness (vécu
épais) of «their» neighbourhood find fewer opportunities to distance the disturbing one, and
feel more negative affects to him. The paper questions the contribution of urban revitalisation
policy in this respect.
Mobile Culture Studies
The Journal, Volume 3/2017
- Title
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Subtitle
- The Journal
- Volume
- 3/2017
- Editor
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2017
- Language
- German, English
- License
- CC BY 4.0
- Size
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Pages
- 198
- Categories
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal