Page - 40 - in Mobile Culture Studies - The Journal, Volume 4/2018
Image of the Page - 40 -
Text of the Page - 40 -
40 Mobile Culture Studies. The Journal 4 2o18
Tuulikki Kurki | Border Crossing Trauma
“I swayed between the two worlds, Fin-
land and Russia, west and east, and I
now stood on this side of the border, still
unsteady.”
(Konkka 1939, 358).
“Was that the border river? How insigni-
ficant it looked, and how different worlds
it demarcated from each other. Two whole
worlds. […] I wish, I could still turn
around, and return home […].”
(Huurre 1942, 11.)
“We had entered a strange country. [...]
I must say, everything seemed very confusing.”
(Tuominen 1957, 248).
Introduction
These examples illustrate the experiences of people who have crossed the Finnish–Russian na-
tional border. They emphasize a sense of disorientation associated with border crossing, that is
often followed by feelings of instability, homelessness and alienation. After crossing a border,
a feeling of disorientation is triggered by the encounter with a “world” that appears strange
and curious, almost like a fantasy. These examples show poignantly the multifaceted nature of
border crossing experiences that are always subject to physical, emotional and cognitive adjust-
ment, and it is difficult to differentiate these elements from each other (Johnson et al. 2011,
62–63).
In its extremity, border crossing can be a traumatic experience. In a hostile environment, a
border crosser can experience or be threatened by witness persecution or even violence. Violence
can be targeted at both social and physical bodies, and the violence itself can be both physical
as well as discursive, and this has the effects of otherizing, humiliating, and desecrating (Aldama
2003, 8). Furthermore, a border crosser may be forced to permanently leave their home and
family, and might not find his or her place in a new country or culture, but rather stay in-between
the different cultures, languages and societies. These sudden or insidious border crossing expe-
riences can shatter the border crosser’s worldview and identity, and these are regarded as being
central signs of cultural trauma (Sztompka 2004, 158–162, 171–175). In addition to personal
experiences, historical events such as wars and border conflicts can traumatize people living in the
borderlands. In these cases, so-called trans-historical traumas move from one generation to an-
other and are “reactivated, reconfigured, and transformed in the present” (LaCapra 1999, 700).
Mobile Culture Studies
The Journal, Volume 4/2018
- Title
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Subtitle
- The Journal
- Volume
- 4/2018
- Editor
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2018
- Language
- German, English
- License
- CC BY 4.0
- Size
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Pages
- 182
- Categories
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal