Seite - 71 - in JRFM - Journal Religion Film Media, Band 04/01
Bild der Seite - 71 -
Text der Seite - 71 -
Intercultural Perspectives |
71www.jrfm.eu
2018, 4/1, 63–77
that above all they exhibit self-pity, as they constantly complain that they were
assigned to this battalion. They had tough luck. They would have preferred to
have been assigned to a battalion that was not ordered to kill Jews. Apparently
Lifton is right. The soldiers express this sentiment loudly and clearly. Nonethe-
less we may wonder whether there is not also something else happening. One
of the soldiers says to his fellow soldiers – I follow here the German text – that
it is impossible to shoot so many Jews. His words are: “Der Anblick der Toten
darunter die Frauen und Kinder ist auch nicht um aufzumuntern” (The sight of
the dead, among them those women and children, does not pep up). This is the
unemotional tough talk of men, but even here we hear that seeing the dead
bodies of women and children causes great mental confusion. While this re-
sponse might be termed self-pity, in my opinion it is rather horror, an intense
feeling of shock accompanied by an indomitable will to run away from this ex-
perience.
For Lifton self-pity means that these soldiers think it dreadful that they be-
long to this battalion while not thinking of what they did to their victims. It may
also be, however, that these words express that they did not want to carry out
this killing and that they will not want to do so in future as well. Later in the film
one of soldiers says that he is afraid that he will never forget, which makes it
impossible for him to return to a normal life. In other words, these memories
will always be with him and will constantly haunt him.
The idea of being haunted by the souls of the dead is entirely absent from
Das radikal Böse. What haunts the soldiers is what they have seen and expe-
rienced. In The Act of Killing, by contrast, people repeatedly talk about being
haunted by the spirits of the dead. I will return later to the important distinction
that this contrast highlights.
THE PARALLEL
Before I turn my attention to this difference, I wish to point to a remarkable
parallel. However great the distance between Eastern Europe and Indonesia,
however different the situations – the massacre of Jews who are deemed not
to belong to the killers’ people and the killing of compatriots – and however far
apart in time the events, the films deal with processes that are also closely akin
to each other.
Both movies deal with a “purification” that has some form of government
backing, a purification of elements that are supposedly no longer at home in
the country where they live. This purification was part of the vision of the gov-
ernment for the future of the country. This vision determined who might be
deemed pure or impure, who was good and who was bad, who had the right to
continue to live and build a future in the country and who had to be removed.
JRFM
Journal Religion Film Media, Band 04/01
- Titel
- JRFM
- Untertitel
- Journal Religion Film Media
- Band
- 04/01
- Autoren
- Christian Wessely
- Daria Pezzoli-Olgiati
- Herausgeber
- Uni-Graz
- Verlag
- SchĂĽren Verlag GmbH
- Ort
- Graz
- Datum
- 2018
- Sprache
- englisch
- Lizenz
- CC BY-NC 4.0
- Abmessungen
- 14.8 x 21.0 cm
- Seiten
- 129
- Kategorien
- Zeitschriften JRFM