Seite - 36 - in >mcs_lab> - Mobile Culture Studies, Band 1/2020
Bild der Seite - 36 -
Text der Seite - 36 -
36 Mobile Culture Studies | >mcs_lab> 1
(2020)Johanna
Menhard | Entanglements on and with the street
Who are the important players in which context? Who or what has the capacity to affect or
to be affected? When I am very occupied by my smartphone and feel anger and distrust toward
its dis-functions and errors, when I sit for hours in shopping centres to have internet access
and am concerned about not being able to check my e-mail while on a walk, I must take care,
because it has the capacity to affect me and my movements on the streets. In this sense the lines
between things and bodies, non-living and living, culture and nature are blurred. As Patricia T.
Clough writes about Massumi s´ approach,
“Massumi’s exemplary illustrations of the autonomy of affect not only show what the body
can do; they show what bodies can be made to do. They show what the body is becoming,
as it meets the limit at a postbiological threshold, which draws to it the dynamism of matter
that had been hidden in oppositions held in place by the body-as-organism, between the
living and the nonliving, the physical and the biological, the natural and the cultural. It is
to this postbiological threshold, I want to argue, that the critical discourses taking up affect,
new media, and biomedia are drawn and with which they are ambivalently engaged.”51
To sum up: Even though affect is mostly framed as an emotional or bodily reaction in
the methodological contexts of ethno-psychoanalysis, it can – as shown here – be useful in a
much broader sense. This can be summed up concisely in the epistemological approach Jens
Wietschorke called Beziehungswissenschaft. He stated that at the core of doing research in
European Ethnology is the thinking, being and setting in relations.52 Therefore, focusing on the
capacity to affect in the context of entanglements on and with the street enables me to elaborate
on technology, bodies, and streets in becoming.
Spring 2019: From intra-action to post-human bodies in motion
As I already pointed out, after I came back from my trip, I went through my field diaries and
notes and came across a lot of very ambiguous affective situations: There was a mixture of feeling
anger, trust, distrust, fear, tender feelings, overload/overextension, disappointment, and so on. I
couldn’t figure out where all these feelings came from. At first, I tried to interpret my field mate-
rial but was not satisfied with the concepts I had in mind and they didn’t fit to the story I sensed
in the material. It felt too mono-directional to ask how the smartphone influenced my movement
on the streets, as if the smartphone made me feel and act this or that way, as if I couldn’t resist or
didn’t have agency in this momentum of feeling. I thought of my smartphone as some sort of old
friend or partner in a dysfunctional relationship that made me feel the ambiguity between trust,
care, distrust, and anger. I wrote a fictional dialogue between me and my smartphone, trying to
figure out what makes up this relationship, but still the relationship was not comprehensible. As
is often the case, reading and feeling affected by a theoretical framework guided my analysis and
51 Patricia T. Clough: The Affective Turn. Political Economy, Biomedia, and Bodies. In: Melissa Gregg/Gregory
Seigworth (eds.): The Affect Theory Reader. Durham/London: Duke University Press 2010. pp. 206-225, here
p. 211.
52 See Jens Wietschorke: Beziehungswissenschaft. Ein Versuch zur volkskundlich-kulturwissenschaftlichen Episte-
mologie. In: Ă–sterreichische Zeitschrift fĂĽr Volkskunde 66 (2012) 3-4, pp. 325-359.
>mcs_lab>
Mobile Culture Studies, Band 1/2020
The Journal
- Titel
- >mcs_lab>
- Untertitel
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Band
- 1/2020
- Herausgeber
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Ort
- Graz
- Datum
- 2020
- Sprache
- deutsch, englisch
- Lizenz
- CC BY 4.0
- Abmessungen
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Seiten
- 108
- Kategorien
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal