Seite - 34 - in Mobile Culture Studies - The Journal, Band 1/2015
Bild der Seite - 34 -
Text der Seite - 34 -
34 Mobile Culture Studies. The Journal 1 2o15
Arnd Schneider | An anthropology of sea voyage
inowski fell out with Witkiewicz, and when Witkiewicz returned from Australia to Europe to
join the Tsar’s army,3Malinowski stayed behind in Australia. Originally from Krakow (then, as
some other parts of Southern Poland, under Austrian rule), Malinowski possessed an Austrian
passport, and therefore in Australia had the status of an enemy alien. Internment in Britain, or
conscription to the Imperial Austrian Army, might have awaited upon his return to Europe, but
in Australia – whilst having to report regularly to the police – Malinowski effectively turned
the prospect of a stay of uncertain length into an opportunity for fieldwork, for which he even
obtained funding (Young 2004: 245-246, Kuper 1983: 12). Importantly, as several commentators
have remarked upon (Young 1998, 2004, Wright 1991, coote 1993), with his artist friend Witkie-
wicz having abandoned him, any potential creative challenge, doubts or threats to Malinowski’s
new realist paradigm of fieldwork were also removed. The paradigm forming character of Mal-
inowski’s first full research trip is also intrinsicially connected with sea voyages of a specific
kind, which were to become the principal topic of his researches – that is the kula ring exchange
system in Trobriand islands; a system of non – monetary exchange that became important in
theoretical debates about exchange systems and economy in non-complex, non-western soci-
eties (starting with Mauss[1925] 1966). The Kula ring consisted of many trading sea voyages
between the islanders of the Trobriands, following an elaborate ceremonial and ritual set of
rules, with long necklaces of red shell moving in one direction and bracelets of white shell
moving into the other, where they are constantly exchanged for each other (Malinowski 1922:
81). however, in terms of actual fieldwork and participant observation Malinowski’s account
of Kula ring voyages is largely reconstructed. Whilst he did do rowing trips close to shore and
went on shorter trips, he never actually joined a kula expedition; in fact he missed one about to
depart (Malinwoski 1922: 385, Young 2004: 539, Stocking 1983: 107). his biographer, Michael W.
Young, has drawn furthermore a neat comparison between Malinowski’s fieldwork founding
myth and that of the Kula ring he investigated:
“Yet anthropological posteriority would come to view his fieldwork achievements as sin-
gularly heroic, and the recursive pattern of his charter myth is discernible even in his brief
expedition to the Amphletts. The hero sails to unknown shores, confronts natural and
supernatural dangers, overcomes obstacles with trickery and magical help and returns safely
with the treasures he has won. In the manner of such heroes, too, he would claim a wife
and rightful fame. Did it perhaps occur to him that his own quest for ethnographic riches
mirrored the heroic quest for fame and fortune of the Kula traders who plied these islands?”
(Young 2004: 539-40)
An entire chapter of Malinowski’s classic monograph is dedicated to shipwreck. Shipwreck is
the one constant of sea travel throughout its history, always present as a threat and possibility
(for the philosophical implications cf. Blumenberg 1996, also Thompson 2014), and Trobriand
Islanders have an elaborate system of magic and spells to make their voyages safe, threatened
incessantly by witches sent by enemies, bad weather (also the result of bad magic), and so forth
(Malinowski 1922: 237 – 266). Malinowski, later famous for his theories on Magic, Science, and
Religion (Malinowski 1948), rationalized his own misfortunes in different ways, but according
3 Witkiewicz was originally from the Lithuanian village of Pašiaušė (or Poszawsze in Polish), then ruled by the
Russian Empire and hence would have travelled on a Russian passport.
Mobile Culture Studies
The Journal, Band 1/2015
- Titel
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Untertitel
- The Journal
- Band
- 1/2015
- Herausgeber
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Ort
- Graz
- Datum
- 2015
- Sprache
- deutsch, englisch
- Lizenz
- CC BY 4.0
- Abmessungen
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Seiten
- 216
- Kategorien
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal