Seite - 28 - in >mcs_lab> - Mobile Culture Studies, Band 2/2020
Bild der Seite - 28 -
Text der Seite - 28 -
28 Mobile Culture Studies. The Journal 6 2o20 (Travel)
Sandra Vlasta | Enlightening report versus enlightened traveller
studies of the objects in question, drawn with incredible skill; further information and descrip-
tions of the images are given in the text. These illustrations thus underscore the extent to which
the voyage was above all an expedition with a scientific purpose, intended to gain a better
understanding of hitherto unknown parts of the world, their inhabitants, and their flora and
fauna. The geographical-political aspect was Captain Cookâs area of responsibility and would
thus feature in his travelogue. The Forsters were hired as natural scientists, though, and this is
reflected in the way the images were chosen and presented in the travelogue. Of course, this
positioning with regard to the illustrations was also a way of making the best of the situation
in which the Forsters found themselves. Deprived of Hodgesâs paintings, the Forsters had to
provide descriptions of people, actual encounters with natives, their way of life, etc., in the text.
In fact, Forster dedicated large sections to these aspects, which interested him greatly. Still, this
side, i.e. the humanist character of his travelogue, obviously written in the philosophical style
that Johann Reinhold Forster had also had in mind, could not be rendered more vivid by actual
pictures of natives. This absence is felt most strongly when Forster refers to paintings by Hodges
that are included in Cookâs report alone, such as the portrait of a man with an expressive face
on the island of Tahuata (Forster 1778â80, vol. 2: 16) or the painting of a turbulent landing in
Tanna (Forster 1778â80, vol. 2: 215). This may give the impression that Forsterâs was a disparate
report, the intention of which could not be realized due to the circumstances. Forsterâs trave-
logue was not received this way, however. Rather, contemporary readers like Alexander von
Humboldt emphasized the new era of travel writing that this book had ushered in, in which
the study of nature was linked in an innovative way to comparative ethnology and geography
and, furthermore, in which clarity was related to universality (see Humboldt 1862: 51). The
perceived novelty of Forsterâs travelogue up to that point has led critics to call him the founder
of modern German travel writing (see Vorpahl 2007: 615; Keller and Siebers 2017: 14). Corre-
spondingly, the images in the book can be read as an integral part of the novel versatility of
Forsterâs writing, which corresponded to the zeitgeist at a time when âhumanist thinking and
scientific insight were seen as two sides of the same coinâ (Vorpahl 2007: 615, my translation).
Furthermore, the illustrations are an example of Forsterâs emphasis on the visual aspect of our
apprehension of the world, which he wrote about later in life, in November 1789, in a letter
to Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi:
Denn am Ende, mehr hat man doch nicht, als was einem durch diese zwei kleinen Oeffnungen der
Pupille fÀllt und die Schwingungen des Gehirns erregt. Anders als so nehmen wir die Welt und ihr
Wesen nicht in uns auf. Die armseligen vier und zwanzig Zeichen reichen nicht aus. [In the end,
one does not have more than that which comes through these two small apertures of the pupils and
stimulates the brainâs vibrations. There is no other way of perceiving the world and its essence. The
pathetic twenty-four signs are not sufficient. (Forster 1981: 371; translation mine)]
Here, Forster stresses the importance of the visual in our perception of the world.11 In the Eng-
lish version of his travelogue, he mainly used words to describe the world, but he was perhaps
retrospectively aware that this only allowed his experience to be conveyed to his readers to a
11 Accordingly, the prominence of the visual has been a major focus in travel writing studies. Only recently have
other senses been taken into account as well, such as sound (Youngs 2019), touch (Jackson 2019), taste (Ober-
holtzer Lee 2019), and smell (Brant 2019).
>mcs_lab>
Mobile Culture Studies, Band 2/2020
The Journal
- Titel
- >mcs_lab>
- Untertitel
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Band
- 2/2020
- Herausgeber
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Ort
- Graz
- Datum
- 2020
- Sprache
- deutsch, englisch
- Lizenz
- CC BY 4.0
- Abmessungen
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Seiten
- 270
- Kategorien
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal