Seite - 44 - in >mcs_lab> - Mobile Culture Studies, Band 2/2020
Bild der Seite - 44 -
Text der Seite - 44 -
44 Mobile Culture Studies. The Journal 6 2o20 (Travel)
Rhian Waller | Postcolonial Pictures
fied meanings may not be recognised as subjective. Chandler argues âwe become so used to
such conventions in our use of various media that they seem ânaturalââ, therefore disguising the
âconventional natureâ (2002: 215) of culturally determined views.
Travel writing traditionally replicated and, arguably, compounded societal inequalities and
colonial attitudes. It was, for instance, originally âa manâs genre, written for and by menâ (McA-
dams, 2014). Blanton points out early travel writers had a tendency to âcarry with them the
unexamined values and norms of their own culture and to judge foreign cultures in light of
those habits of belief [âŠ] establishing a kind of control over themâ (2013: 8). Thompson notes
the âpatricianâ tendencies of travel writers whose âfreedom to roam the globe was [âŠ] predica-
ted to some extent on the privileges accruing from their social standingâ (2011: 59). The privilege
that facilitates the travel writerâs movements may run alongside a corresponding de-privileging
of the host culture by reducing subjects to stereotype through âsweeping judgementsâ (Thomp-
son, 2011: 90) or by encoding discriminatory racial and cultural messages, where a place or
people is diminished, Othered and limited âto the role of propsâ (Achebe, 1990: 124). Orienta-
lism (Said, 1978) and similarly problematic depictions of Africa (Youngs, 1994), wherein Asian
and African cultures and people are constructed in text and images as alien, savage and inferior,
are both symptoms and mechanisms of this process.
The aspects of Victorian travel writing that support colonialism and western expansionism
is discussed in detail by Pratt (2008), who picks apart the written subjectivities of âmasteryâ,
some of which persist into the 20th century. Blanton is more generous toward contemporary
travel writing, âwhere values are discovered, not imported [âŠ] where other cultures can have
their sayâ (2013: 29).
Duffy and Mangharam question the application of postcolonial analysis to modern travel
writing, arguing that, as economies such as China take on roles of global dominance, new
power dynamics are emerging. However, they acknowledge touristic travel reproduces the
âdominance/subordination of the visitor-host relationshipâ (2017). It is important to note travel
writing and visual art carried out within a postcolonial setting may be âinformed by imperia-
list attitudes and ideologiesâ (Thompson, 2011: 136), as cultural attitudes persist long after the
structures and institutions that rely upon and uphold them crumble. Furthermore, artefacts
that support âsoft powerâ and neo-colonialism may emerge as Western economies attempt to
sustain âpolitical and economic dominance over the rest of the worldâ (Thompson, 2011: 136).
Increasing global competition may in fact encourage writers and ideologues to fall into proble-
matic patterns of discourse.
This ideological encoding may not be conscious or intentional, and it may not be direct.
Signs do not operate in isolation. Images and text are comprised of collections of signifiers, so
meaning is subject to diffusion, wherein close proximity between concepts results in a bleed-
over. For instance, Jacobs (2014) argues that due to repeated association between the sign
âschool violenceâ and particular attacking behaviours, the phrase has come to be associated
almost exclusively with physical violence, which minimises and ignores other forms of violence.
Likewise, Lido (2006) and Dietrich et al (2006) illustrate how readers presented with a story
that mentions particular people with mental illness or asylum seeker status engaging in nega-
tive activities are more likely to perceive all mentally ill people or asylum seekers as a source of
higher risk, despite compelling statistical evidence that this is inaccurate.
>mcs_lab>
Mobile Culture Studies, Band 2/2020
The Journal
- Titel
- >mcs_lab>
- Untertitel
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Band
- 2/2020
- Herausgeber
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Ort
- Graz
- Datum
- 2020
- Sprache
- deutsch, englisch
- Lizenz
- CC BY 4.0
- Abmessungen
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Seiten
- 270
- Kategorien
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal