Seite - 141 - in >mcs_lab> - Mobile Culture Studies, Band 2/2020
Bild der Seite - 141 -
Text der Seite - 141 -
Mobile Culture Studies. The Journal 6 2o20 (Travel)
Birgit Englert | On the (Im)possibility of Writing a Travelogue 141
illustration, that is, to âenlightenâ or âto light upâ a textâ (Walchester 2019: 127), Ramos makes
clear in his introduction that
the drawings in this book [can] only be called âethnographic illustrationsâ in the very broadest of
terms. They are not intended to illustrate any particular passage of the text. Rather, they illustrate
the personal and cultural limitations of my gaze and are evidence of my visual fascination with an
intensely different world. (Ramos 2018: 6)
For Ramos, sketchers belong to a category of their own. As he notes:
A sketcher adopts less of an imperialist attitude to ârepresentationâ than a photographer, a film-
maker, a journalist, or an anthropologist. As the travel sketch is more constrained (by the urge
to sketch, the poverty of the materials used and the limitation of the technique) and for that very
reason freer from the demands of mimesis, it does not even pretend to âdescribeâ or âreproduceâ
any particular reality as experienced or observed. (Ramos 2018: 2)
The âimperfectionâ of the sketch thus becomes an advantage in the sense that the impossibility
of representing the world âas it isâ is evident at first glance. The potential to be misunderstood
and to be taken as wanting to offer explanation and representation is thus considerably reduced
â something Ramos claims ethnographic texts are unable to do as they âcan never escape the
overpowering will to âmeanâ â that is, to reduce alien realities to oneâs own words and catego-
riesâ (Ramos 2018: 2). By resorting to the technique of sketching, Ramos aims to avoid giving
the impression that he can offer anything beyond glimpses into what caught his attention while
travelling in Ethiopia.
Ramosâs book(s)
Of Hairy Kings and Saintly Slaves: An Ethiopian Travelogue was published in 20187 and is
an English translation8 of the Portuguese book HistĂłrias EtĂopes. DiĂĄrio de Viagem, which
appeared in 2010. This book was itself âa deep re-writingâ of a book with the same title that had
been published in 2000 (personal communication with Ramos, 20.9.2020).
An Ethiopian Travelogue was published in the UK by Sean Kingston Publishing, which
specializes in anthropology. As the high price of the hardcover book (60 pounds in the UK, 90
dollars in the US) clearly indicates, the book is primarily targeted at an academic readership.9
The Portuguese versions were published by the Lisbon-based publishing houses AssĂrio &
Alvim (2000) and EdiçÔes Tinta da China (2010), respectively. In the following analysis, I will
mainly focus on the English version that was published in 2018, although I will identify the
ways in which it differs from the previously published Portuguese versions.
The âHistĂłrias EtĂopesâ (âEthiopian Historiesâ) of the Portuguese versions are echoed in the
words of the first part of the English title: Of Hairy Kings and Saintly Slaves, although neither
kings nor slaves are visually depicted on the cover image of the English edition. It is composed
7 So far, the book has been discussed in two reviews, albeit from an anthropological (Lam 2019) and a historical
perspective (Wion 2019), respectively, and without focusing on the book as a piece of travel writing.
8 The translation into English was made by Christopher Tribe.
Cf. <https://www.seankingston.co.uk/pubframe.html#RAMO01.> [accessed on: 21.09.2020]
9 Cf. the publisherâs website: <https://www.seankingston.co.uk/pubframe.html#RAMO01.> [accessed on: 21.09.2020]
>mcs_lab>
Mobile Culture Studies, Band 2/2020
The Journal
- Titel
- >mcs_lab>
- Untertitel
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Band
- 2/2020
- Herausgeber
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Ort
- Graz
- Datum
- 2020
- Sprache
- deutsch, englisch
- Lizenz
- CC BY 4.0
- Abmessungen
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Seiten
- 270
- Kategorien
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal