Seite - 139 - in Mobile Culture Studies - The Journal, Band 3/2017
Bild der Seite - 139 -
Text der Seite - 139 -
Mobile Culture Studies. The Journal 3 2o17
Patrick Naef | Using mobility and urban planning to implement atmosphere 139
social worlds.’ (Buser 2014, 239) A sensitive approach to public space, including inhabitant
perspectives, cannot be entirely planned in an engineer’s office. Ground-level experience is thus
fundamental to identifying successes and failures, and making the necessary corrections. When
he presents the two concurrent approaches mentioned above, ‘to divide’ or, in opposition, ‘to
share’, Soulier (2010, 252) underlines the complexity of the second one: ‘the first one is func-
tionalist, normative and simplistic. It coincides with the division of power and funding, with
the private grounds and flower beds of one and the other; the second one implies experiments,
confusions, compromises, taking risks.’
The examples presented in this analysis confirm the importance of this reflexive process,
drawing on evaluations and corrections, which will help the population to appropriate these
new urban developments. Based on the results collected so far, a bridge period ranging from six
months to one year seems necessary for the population to grasp these new mobility codes. Even
after this transitory period, encounter zones should not be frozen in time, but open to future
changes in parallel with the evolution of urban societies. As the mayor of Versoix states: ‘In ge-
neral we need at least six months of adaptation. I had a colleague who wanted to regulate everything
once and for all. But it is important to wait for things to happen… For people to learn to share this
space.’ (personal communication, 15 September 2016). His colleague, the chief of urbanism
supports this statement: ‘We need to stop, to look at what is going on, and if corrections are needed
we intervene. (personal communication, 15 September 2016). In Versoix and Fribourg, a pe-
riod of inertia, as some of the stakeholders describe it, lead for instance some shop keepers to
take these changes on board or the planners to add street furniture to a specific site. Finding a
solution that suits everyone – inhabitants and users, business owners of all types, architects, de-
signers, magistrates – is challenging and complaints will often arise. Thus, a process that leaves
room for participation, criticisms and corrections, can certainly contribute to a more optimal
development. The mobilization of atmospheres in urban planning can pave the way to a more
integrative conception of public space.
Conclusion
This analysis sought to examine whether encounter zones in Switzerland could contribute to
disseminating atmospheres favouring the appropriation of the street by pedestrians. Case stu-
dies featured in this study were two medium-sized urban localities providing interesting insights
into possible ways of revitalizing a public place. It has been demonstrated that encounter zones
could indeed act as a tool that has a greater effect than that of simply regulating the traffic.
Indeed, if well managed, such developments could represent opportunities for implementing
atmospheres associated with conviviality and contributing to what Rachel Thomas conceptua-
lizes as the ‘anchorage’ of pedestrians.
To achieve this result, stakeholders should reflect on their practice and be ready to make
modifications and corrections if necessary. This can already be illustrated by an institutional
protocol in the whole country based on the evaluation of encounter zones one year after their
inauguration. In both cases – Versoix and Fribourg – new measures had to be put in place. It
has also been shown that the success of encounter zones – in terms of atmosphere as well as
speed regulation – is contextual. Encounter zones should be installed in places already used
by pedestrians and a thorough reflection should be conducted on the layout of areas seen as
Mobile Culture Studies
The Journal, Band 3/2017
- Titel
- Mobile Culture Studies
- Untertitel
- The Journal
- Band
- 3/2017
- Herausgeber
- Karl Franzens University Graz
- Ort
- Graz
- Datum
- 2017
- Sprache
- deutsch, englisch
- Lizenz
- CC BY 4.0
- Abmessungen
- 21.0 x 29.7 cm
- Seiten
- 198
- Kategorien
- Zeitschriften Mobile Culture Studies The Journal