Page - 265 - in Book of Full Papers - Symposium Hydro Engineering
Image of the Page - 265 -
Text of the Page - 265 -
acceptable risk level frequently serves for decision-making after balancing the
cost against benefits from that risk. ALAPR (As low as reasonably practicable) is a
widely used acceptable risk criterion which involves unacceptably high risk,
generally acceptable risk and negligible risk [1]. The acceptable risk level lies
between unacceptably high risk region and generally acceptable risk region,
which determines the feasibility. HSE (The Health and Safety Executive)
proposed that risk of existing infrastructure is annual fatality risk of 10-4 [2].
Concerned with the acceptable risk of dam safety, USBR (United States Bureau
of Reclamation) and ANCOLD (Australian National Committee on Large Dams)
suggested 10-2 and 10-3 fatalities/person/year for each dam failure event
respectively, while BC Hydro presented the acceptable life and economic risk
associated with each dam failure is of 10-3 fatalities/person/year and
US$7120/year respectively [3].
Risk depends on probability of failure and loss of hazard. The loss varies
with time and place, is closely related to the development of local economy and
society, while failure probability can be approached by statistics and simulations.
In this article, we focus on dam failure probability. According to analysis on
different dam failure modes, flood related problems including flood exceeding
control criterion and spillway failure both leading to erosion damage on dams and
bank joint, which accounts for one third of overall dam failure events. The dam in
United States which were built after 1950s with a height more than 30m is of a
failure probability in the range of 1.3×10-3~3.0×10-3. It indicates [4] the dam failure
caused by flood related problems is in the range of 0.43×10-3~1.0×10-3. Yang et
al[4] considered 10-3~10-4 on the lower side of criterion for dam safety and flood
control. Regardless of flood regulation, Xu [5] provided 10-5 as risk probability of
spillway for high dam. As the technology of design, construction and management
for dams and reservoirs improved, dam failure events reduced. In China, from
1990 to 2011, there were 278 dam failed in the overall approximately 98000 dams
[6]. It offered a dam failure probability of 2.84×10-4 and deduced that probability of
flood related risk is 9.47×10-5.
The probability of flood related problems could be attained by numerical
simulation as well as statistics. Xu [7] attributed flood-related risk to large flood and
failure of spillway, and applied JC method to risk calculation. The P-III and normal
distribution were used to describe the uncertainty of flood inflow and initial stage
respectively, while triangle and normal distribution were applied to describe the
uncertainty of spillways capacity. Based on stochastic simulation approach, Mei et
al [8] took both hydrological and hydraulic uncertainty into account, used seasonal
AR(1) models to generate a great number of reservoir inflow. The results revealed
that flood-related hydrological uncertainty plays the major role in risk analysis
compared with any other factors.
Based on stochastic simulation, we researched in the view of: (1) dam
safety itself, (2) flood control capability of dam and, (3) flood control for
downstream regions provided by dam. The case study is 4 built cascade
reservoirs in the Jinsha River, China. Based on statistical parameters obtained
from observed 49-year flood peak series of 3 hydrological stations in the study
area, climate change is studied and stochastic simulation is adopted to reflect the
uncertainty of flood inflow. The calculation and procedure will contribute to
265
Book of Full Papers
Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Title
- Book of Full Papers
- Subtitle
- Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Author
- Gerald Zenz
- Publisher
- Verlag der Technischen Universität Graz
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2018
- Language
- English
- License
- CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
- ISBN
- 978-3-85125-620-8
- Size
- 20.9 x 29.6 cm
- Pages
- 2724
- Keywords
- Hydro, Engineering, Climate Changes
- Categories
- International
- Naturwissenschaften Physik
- Technik