Page - 2075 - in Book of Full Papers - Symposium Hydro Engineering
Image of the Page - 2075 -
Text of the Page - 2075 -
cover. These safety factors apply to unlined tunnels, disregarding the reinforced
liner with consolidation grouting. Therefore, hydrojacking because of low cover
cannot constitute the sole cause of the failure. A FEM simulation of the stress
distribution in the failed section supports this conclusion. As Figure 6 shows, the
TfX layer causes a distortion of the stress field in the ridge, raising σ3 near the
tunnel to arrive at levels similar to that derived from the Lugeon tests (cf. [18] for
similar effects).
Figure 6
σ3 contours for cross section at tunnel failure according to FEM simulation
Simulation MEF des contours σ3 en coupe transversale près de la rupture
Looking for an explanation for the tunnel failure, the effect of tensile stresses
caused by seepage water around the tunnel was also evaluated [according to [11,
12]). Allowing for an uncertainty in the hydrogeological regime, two alternatives
were studied, with 46.5 m external head, as suggested by the piezometer data
from the exploratory borehole, and 17 m, as implied by a hydrogeological model
introducing a drainage effect due to TfX. For the alternatives, the Fernandez
method estimated seepage losses between 0.1 and 0.27 l/s/m (which agreed
closely with the results of a hydrogeological simulation) and an average crack width
of less than 0.1mm. Estimates following [8, 9] indicated a crack width of up 0.14mm
and seepage of 0.38 l/s/m. Thus, also these approaches did not explain the failure
of the tunnel. Still other factors and processes must have contributed. In this
context, the study of Lugeon and dilatometer tests gives hints: Lugeon values had
notably increased (Figure 4) after the incident, but the deformation modulus had
not changed, hydrogeological characteristics were more notably affected than
mechanical. The crack in the concrete of block 342 was opened 5mm but the
continuation into the breccia gaped 2cm. At the slope failure, the water issued from
pipes in the TfX layer. Apparently, the clastic dike had collected seepage water
and eroded the breccia and dispersivity of TfX had permitted rapid piping. This
means, a geological detail – the clastic dike – and a local condition – the
pronounced dispersivity – had prominently assisted in the failure process.
Hydrogeologic modelling, assuming high infiltration rates exceeding 600
mm/year, failed to reproduce the groundwater level found in the exploratory
boreholes. Therefore, in the original state, the overburden (young tuffs, residual
2075
Book of Full Papers
Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Title
- Book of Full Papers
- Subtitle
- Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Author
- Gerald Zenz
- Publisher
- Verlag der Technischen Universität Graz
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2018
- Language
- English
- License
- CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
- ISBN
- 978-3-85125-620-8
- Size
- 20.9 x 29.6 cm
- Pages
- 2724
- Keywords
- Hydro, Engineering, Climate Changes
- Categories
- International
- Naturwissenschaften Physik
- Technik