Page - 2126 - in Book of Full Papers - Symposium Hydro Engineering
Image of the Page - 2126 -
Text of the Page - 2126 -
Even with allowance for accuracy of the test results, they unquestionably
establish σh/σv<1. This fact was to be taken into account in the design of the
headrace tunnel and eventually called for a substantial extension of the steel liner
in upstream direction. This had two consequences for the project: (a) added cost
for the steel liner and (b) problems with the construction time schedule. The cost
for delayed commissioning of the plant was the more serious aspect and remedial
measures were taken in this regard, to the best possible extend. A long bypass
tunnel allowed opening of additional working fronts and saving of time.
Figure 9 shows the distribution of applied lining types, along pressure tunnel
chainage up to power cavern. Thanks to the installation of these linings, performance
of the completed tunnel was overall very good, without mayor leakages observed.
CONCLUSION
The literature lists ample precedence of unlined pressure tunnels with
satisfactory performance and offers empiric and semi-empiric methods and criteria
for their design, e. g. Blind et al. [5], Broch [3], Buen et al. [6], Deere [7], Palmström
et al., [8]. However, Benson [9] described the complexity of the subject and Swiger
[10] questioned the use of rules of thumb. Schleiss ([11], [12]), Hendron et al. [13]
and Fernandez ([14], [15]) analyzed the hydrogeological effects on the perfor-
mance of pressure tunnels.
The uncertainties, critical for the design of the Quitaracsa headrace tunnel,
were identified in time for the required investigations and adjustments. Without
these adjustments, the Quitaracsa tunnel would have failed and required extensive
repair works, resulting in a long interruption of plant operation with high conse-
quential loss of production.
Under conditions similar to those present at Quitaracsa, empirical methods
for the design of pressure tunnels can offer a reasonable approach in early stages
of a project, but for final design it must be carefully checked if the assumptions
inherent to such methods do apply. This was not the case for the Quitaracsa tunnel
and similar experience was also made on other projects. The uncertainties, critical
for the design of the Quitaracsa pressure tunnel, were identified in time for the
required investigations and adjustments. Without these, extensive repair works
would have resulted in long interruptions of plant operation and loss of production.
In this context, the experience with the Quitaracsa pressure tunnel serves as
an example of exception from the rules and demonstrates the need for reliable and
representative information on rock mechanical and hydrogeological conditions,
particularly for projects with medium or high pressure tunnels.
2126
Book of Full Papers
Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Title
- Book of Full Papers
- Subtitle
- Symposium Hydro Engineering
- Author
- Gerald Zenz
- Publisher
- Verlag der Technischen Universität Graz
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2018
- Language
- English
- License
- CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
- ISBN
- 978-3-85125-620-8
- Size
- 20.9 x 29.6 cm
- Pages
- 2724
- Keywords
- Hydro, Engineering, Climate Changes
- Categories
- International
- Naturwissenschaften Physik
- Technik