Page - 138 - in Critical Issues in Science, Technology and Society Studies - Conference Proceedings of the 17th STS Conference Graz 2018
Image of the Page - 138 -
Text of the Page - 138 -
Interviews with actors involved in field tests
Semi-structured interviews with actors involved in field test installations should help answer the
question of the socio-technical factors influencing the quality of installed cold systems which
work as drivers or barriers to the increased dissemination of the innovation. This should also
shed light on how these local experiments work as the drivers of change by contributing to
alignment of expectations, network building, and learning.
Interviewees included representatives of facility management, planners, energy suppliers,
decision-makers, and researchers involved in seven field tests. The interview guide focused on
their experiences during the planning, installation and launching process of the absorption
refrigeration systems.
Results
Interview results reveal differentiated information, especially about learning processes taking
place, but also regarding the development of expectations among participants of field tests and
their contribution to network development.
Learning processes and effects concern various aspects: Technology itself, user context and
demand, (cooperation during) planning process, knowledge and know-how, economic
efficiency and perspectives, and regulative framework conditions. In the following, I present
selected main results concerning technology, user context, planning process, and economic
aspects.
Learning effects related to technology
Interview results reveal that the innovation fulfills practitioners’ expectations regarding lower size,
weight and space requirements. Despite current problems or negative experiences, actors
believe in the future of absorption refrigeration technology and are ready to invest time and
money. Nevertheless, results show that the technology is perceived as demanding. Practice
actors had difficulty understanding the functionality of the plant which would have been
necessary for some fundamental decisions which had to be taken at an early stage of planning
process. Due to a lack of understanding, decisions had to be revised in some cases when the
effects of decisions for other parameters became visible.
Learning effects related to user context
Often, new refrigeration systems must be introduced into existing building energy systems. This
implies planning based on very little data about the existing technology system and cold
demand, as, in many cases, “measuring was always a foreign concept”, as one interviewee
said. The innovative technology often needs to be integrated into aged, patchwork-like systems,
partly with components which are not compatible with the requirements of the new technology.
Adaptations and/or exchange of components in the existing building energy system (with
respective additional costs) and/or compromises are necessary. These context conditions
usually limit possible energy efficiency.
Additionally, a contrast between the “full automation” vision (of researchers) and current
practices occurred. Today, many systems are serviced by staff-members who know the existing
building energy system and keep it running despite lacking data and information, based on their
practical experience and tacit knowledge. The question is not only if these actors are willing to
138
Critical Issues in Science, Technology and Society Studies
Conference Proceedings of the 17th STS Conference Graz 2018
- Title
- Critical Issues in Science, Technology and Society Studies
- Subtitle
- Conference Proceedings of the 17th STS Conference Graz 2018
- Editor
- Technische Universität Graz
- Publisher
- Verlag der Technischen Universität Graz
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2018
- Language
- English
- License
- CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
- ISBN
- 978-3-85125-625-3
- Size
- 21.6 x 27.9 cm
- Pages
- 214
- Keywords
- Kritik, TU, Graz, TU Graz, Technologie, Wissenschaft
- Categories
- International
- Tagungsbände
- Technik