Page - 182 - in Critical Issues in Science, Technology and Society Studies - Conference Proceedings of the 17th STS Conference Graz 2018
Image of the Page - 182 -
Text of the Page - 182 -
editor of the blog cuncti, and GĂĽnter Buchholz, who is responsible coordinator for the platform
gender-diskurs.de.1 Gerhard Amendt is a key figure of the male right movement which often
uses his scientific authority for their goals (e.g. see an interview with him on the male right-
platform MANNdat 2014). Amend is founding member of agens.e.v. which is an association
promoting heteronormative and essentialist views on gender and gender roles2.
This shows that, as also a number of studies (Kováts/Põim 2015, Kemper 2014, Lang 2015,
Gehrmann et al. 2015) have pointed out, antifeminist positions like those of the gender critic
scientists serve as a link between different groups of actors of the new conservative right.
Antifeminism covers ideological differences and thus allows coalitions between conservative,
traditional, religious-fundamentalist and radical right-wing groups and movements, a network
which is composed of the AfD, PEGIDA which is the radical right movement against the
islamization of the Christian occident, the neo-nazi Identitarian movement and their think tanks
like the journal “Junge Freiheit”, the so-called Institut für Staatspolitik (institute for state policy),
the publisher antaios, the Zivile Koalition (civil coalition) and the Demo fĂĽr alle movement.
All of these groups state a societal crisis and perceive the modernization of gender relationships
as a threat to society, to children and to traditional values and life forms like marriage. A part of
the middle class tries to mobilize the precarious or those who are threatened by precariousness,
and who fear to lose their privileges. Apart from the liberalization of gender relationships, thus
also for example migration is problematized.
Some of the scientists criticizing gender studies are also involved in such discourses; Gerhard
Amendt depicts muslim male migrants on agens.ev in a culturalist way as savages who molest
women because of their tribal origins and who can only be handled by a brutal police force
(Amendt 2016a). Also, Ulrich Kutschera warns of “young, testosterone-driven men” and speaks
of an “religious motivated African war against german women” (Kutschera 2016: 402; 2018).
Historical Parallels
Historical parallels can be seen regarding antifeminist movements at the beginning of the 20st
century: as Ute Planert (1998) points out, during the German Empire, antifeminist activities
emerged in reaction to the liberalization of gender relations. In addition, back then, antifeminism
was connected to antisemitism (Volkov 2000), which is also today the case, as the popular
conspiracy theory that feminism had been invented by Rockefeller and Rothschild shows3.
Even at the beginning of the 20th century, science was used as final justification. For example in
1900, a neurological essay on the physiological imbecility of women was published (Möbius
1901). philosophers of the time like Schopenhauer have held misogynist views – a worthwhile
reading on this is Annegret Stopczik´s collection of philosophers statements on women
(Stopczyk 1997).
Back then and today, specific naturalized gender characteristics were assumed. However, in
contrast to those historical antifeminist argumentations, a discoursive shift has taken place: at
the beginning of the 20th century and beyond, women were denied the same rights as men,
1 See https://sciencefiles.org/tag/dr-habil-heike-diefenbach/, http://www.cuncti.net/autoren/2-autor/?uid=ulfig-
alexander, and http://www.gender-diskurs.de/kontakt/.
2 See their homepage https://agensev.de/.
3 See for example an accordant thread on the blog “Alles Schall und Rauch”, http://alles-
schallundrauch.blogspot.de/2006/12/der-ursprung-des-feminismus.html.
182
Critical Issues in Science, Technology and Society Studies
Conference Proceedings of the 17th STS Conference Graz 2018
- Title
- Critical Issues in Science, Technology and Society Studies
- Subtitle
- Conference Proceedings of the 17th STS Conference Graz 2018
- Editor
- Technische Universität Graz
- Publisher
- Verlag der Technischen Universität Graz
- Location
- Graz
- Date
- 2018
- Language
- English
- License
- CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
- ISBN
- 978-3-85125-625-3
- Size
- 21.6 x 27.9 cm
- Pages
- 214
- Keywords
- Kritik, TU, Graz, TU Graz, Technologie, Wissenschaft
- Categories
- International
- Tagungsbände
- Technik