Page - 227 - in VULNERABLE - The Law, Policy and Ethics of COVID-19
Image of the Page - 227 -
Text of the Page - 227 -
227Liability
of the Crown in Times of Pandemic
behaviour either.14 The Ontario CLPA states clearly under section 8(2):
“For greater certainty, nothing in clause (1) (a) subjects the Crown to
liability for a tort that is not attributable to the acts or omissions of an
officer, employee or agent of the Crown.” In short, if the servant can-
not be sued, the chain is broken and the Crown is free from liability.
Servants of the Crown are not immune from suit and can be
sued before ordinary courts according to ordinary law.15 But indi-
vidual civil servants are not likely to have the deep pockets neces-
sary to make large payouts after successful lawsuits. Moreover, under
the CLPA, the Crown is not liable for its own fault. Therefore, where
harm is caused by institutional failures that cannot be attributed to
identifiable individuals over long periods of time the Crown is not
liable—as was the case in Hinse, where a claim for damages based on
the Federal Minister of Justice’s refusal to exercise Crown’s power of
mercy failed.16 Following Hinse, it would not be possible, for example,
to sue the “Minister” or the “Government” generally for a series of
decisions taken over the years in relation to, for instance, the funding
of research on novel coronaviruses.
Public Law Immunity: Immunity for Policy Decisions
The belief in current legal thinking that the Crown is immune at com-
mon law also subverts the CLPA and its provincial equivalents in a
different way. While these statutes clearly establish recourse in tort
against the Crown, courts have nevertheless developed a substantial
body of law distinguishing governmental policy decisions (which are
shielded from judicial scrutiny) from operational aspects. Moreover,
the scope of “policy” decisions continues to grow, to the detriment of
“operational” measures.
In R v Imperial Tobacco Canada Ltd. (Imperial), the Court defined
“core policy” decisions shielded from suit as, “decisions as to a course
or principle of action that are based on public policy considerations,
such as economic, social and political factors, provided they are nei-
ther irrational nor taken in bad faith.”17 This description is potentially
very broad. As has been noted before, “Policy and operational acts
14. CLPA, supra note 3, s 10.
15. Albert Venn Dicey, The Oxford Edition of Dicey, ed by JWF Allison (Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 2013) at 100.
16. Hinse v Canada (Attorney General), 2015 SCC 35 [Hinse].
17. 2011 SCC 42 at para 90 [Imperial].
VULNERABLE
The Law, Policy and Ethics of COVID-19
- Title
- VULNERABLE
- Subtitle
- The Law, Policy and Ethics of COVID-19
- Authors
- Vanessa MacDonnell
- Jane Philpott
- Sophie Thériault
- Sridhar Venkatapuram
- Publisher
- Ottawa Press
- Date
- 2020
- Language
- English
- License
- CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
- ISBN
- 9780776636429
- Size
- 15.2 x 22.8 cm
- Pages
- 648
- Categories
- Coronavirus
- International