Page - 896 - in The Complete Plato

SOCRATES: The only remaining alternative is that the soul apprehends the replenishment by the help of memory; as is obvious, for what other way can there be? PROTARCHUS: I cannot imagine any other. SOCRATES: But do you see the consequence? PROTARCHUS: What is it? SOCRATES: That there is no such thing as desire of the body. PROTARCHUS: Why so? SOCRATES: Why, because the argument shows that the endeavour of every animal is to the reverse of his bodily state. PROTARCHUS: Yes. SOCRATES: And the impulse which leads him to the opposite of what he is experiencing proves that he has a memory of the opposite state. PROTARCHUS: True. SOCRATES: And the argument, having proved that memory attracts us towards the objects of desire, proves also that the impulses and the desires and the moving principle in every living being have their origin in the soul. PROTARCHUS: Most true. SOCRATES: The argument will not allow that our body either hungers or thirsts or has any similar experience. PROTARCHUS: Quite right. SOCRATES: Let me make a further observation; the argument appears to me to imply that there is a kind of life which consists in these affections. PROTARCHUS: Of what affections, and of what kind of life, are you speaking? SOCRATES: I am speaking of being emptied and replenished, and of all that relates to the preservation and destruction of living beings, as well as of the pain which is felt in one of these states and of the pleasure which succeeds to it. PROTARCHUS: True. SOCRATES: And what would you say of the intermediate state? PROTARCHUS: What do you mean by ‘intermediate’? SOCRATES: I mean when a person is in actual suffering and yet 896