Seite - 920 - in The Complete Plato

SOCRATES: The one majestic ever, the other inferior. PROTARCHUS: You speak riddles. SOCRATES: You have seen loves good and fair, and also brave lovers of them. PROTARCHUS: I should think so. SOCRATES: Search the universe for two terms which are like these two and are present everywhere. PROTARCHUS: Yet a third time I must say, Be a little plainer, Socrates. SOCRATES: There is no difficulty, Protarchus; the argument is only in play, and insinuates that some things are for the sake of something else (relatives), and that other things are the ends to which the former class subserve (absolutes). PROTARCHUS: Your many repetitions make me slow to understand. SOCRATES: As the argument proceeds, my boy, I dare say that the meaning will become clearer. PROTARCHUS: Very likely. SOCRATES: Here are two new principles. PROTARCHUS: What are they? SOCRATES: One is the generation of all things, and the other is essence. PROTARCHUS: I readily accept from you both generation and essence. SOCRATES: Very right; and would you say that generation is for the sake of essence, or essence for the sake of generation? PROTARCHUS: You want to know whether that which is called essence is, properly speaking, for the sake of generation? SOCRATES: Yes. PROTARCHUS: By the gods, I wish that you would repeat your question. SOCRATES: I mean, O my Protarchus, to ask whether you would tell me that ship-building is for the sake of ships, or ships for the sake of ship- building? and in all similar cases I should ask the same question. PROTARCHUS: Why do you not answer yourself, Socrates? SOCRATES: I have no objection, but you must take your part. PROTARCHUS: Certainly. 920